GRUMPY'S SOURDOUGH PIZZA CO. – Experience the Best Sourdough Pizza in Saddle Brook

I rarely write reviews. This is hands down the best pizza I’ve ever had. We ordered drunken grandma and pepperoni tonight. It’s thin, crunchy. It tastes like what a cartoon pizza looks like. I can’t describe it any other way.

Amazing pizza! Probably one of the best around in North Jersey. We had plain with Garlic crust, Grandma pizza with garlic crust, and Spinach and Artichoke with plain crust so far and all were very good. If you're looking for different flavor profiles of pizza and something non-traditional, this place is it! I will also note, I've been here on three different occasions and Saturday late afternoon seems to be one of their busiest days. We waited about 50 minutes so if you are in a rush, plan ahead. While waiting for my order, I was observing the staff working through an organized chaos and I must say it was impressive! Every single team member, from the girl taking orders, to the delivery drivers helping build pizza boxes while they wait for their next delivery, BOH pushing out all the orders coming in, and the owner communicating to the guests in the shop about their orders - amazing team work! Keep up the great work! Also, loved the music playing!

The parking situation was honestly hilarious but that pizza was so so so so so so good. The texture of the crust was immaculate and the flavor bursting in my mouth was a heavenly experience. This pizza is a must try. 10/10 would recommend. I practically DRANK it like juice. (Also that basil was FREEEEESH)

Grumpy’s Pizza Co. Great Service and Delicious Food!!!! Our first time ordering and we experienced eating at home due to we were blessed for this Christmas Day with an honorary gift card a very blessed gifting amount from a generous donating organization !!They are very polite and intuitive to your quality of food I asked for what I wanted and they satisfied my requests. There were a few very minor offsets but overall the food was tasty and very very delicious My children enjoyed the pizza, their response was “WE NEED TO ALWAYS ORDER FROM THERE AGAIN!” So there you are if and when my children enjoyed and like the food I was very happy!!!! Promise to provide food pics next time!!!! The delicious food was worth the amount we spent 105.00, definitely worth it!!! We loved the food and prompt service, Great Job!!! Conclusion of the Grumpy’s Gift Card Donated & Funded By “LIVE LIKE MADDIE FOUNDATION” a very loving and caring family they were the ones who donated to our White-Franklin Family. The founders of “LIVE LIKE MADDIE FOUNDATION” daughter who is no longer a student due to she’s deceased but was a student too and now my son is a current student and our family was a chosen recipient to receive a “GRUMPY’S RESTAURANT GIFT CARD” thru CHILDREN’S THERAPY CENTER ACADEMY for this past December 25, 2024 Christmas Holiday. It was a very kind and generous monetary gift and we are forever grateful and thankful to the LIVE LIKE MADDIE FOUNDATION because of them they united and brought together GRUMPY’S RESTAURANT FAMILY IN SADDLEBROOK, NEW JERSEY business and the WHITE-FRANKLIN family will be a long term customer for life and we thank you from the bottom of our hearts THE BEST PIZZA AND GREATEST SERVICE , WE LOVE YOU GRUMPY’S PIZZA, thank you for your service, your business, your kind hospitality and friendship . A PLACE WITH A TASTE THAT LEAVES YOU WANTING MORE!!!! Go there and I promise you it will be worth your money and satisfaction guaranteed to your “TASTEBUDS!!!! We exhausted our gift card but will be reloading soon to visit and order again!!! “THAT’S AMORRRRRRRE!!!!!”

What a fantastic find! New to the area and came across Grumpy's on Google. Decided to give them a try to feed friends and family during the move. Ordered 6 pies; 3 cheese, 1 BBQ chicken, 1 Meat Haters (veggie) and 1 pepperoni. All were delicious especially the BBQ chicken. The fresh basil is a nice touch. The customer service was impeccable from ordering to delivery. They forgot the plates and sent another person to deliver. Phenomenal! Would highly recommend.

Mom and I were in the area, we live an hour south. we wanted to grab some lunch so I googled what was around me. As i scrolled, i stopped when i saw “sourdough pizza” and thought “what no way, we have to go there” Well, we got two personal pizza The eggplant rollatini and the grandma pie and i regretted that decision later on that day... Why you may ask, because I didn’t have left overs!!! I grew up in the pizzeria being italian and my family owning a pizzeria i’m usually like, oh the sauce is too sour, or gosh they added too much sugar bc they don’t know how to balance the flavors. Mom is even pickier! So for us to both say this pizza was great is like gordon ramsey himself approving it. lol you know bc he’s super critical! lol anyway The sauce was amazing it was the perfect balance of sweetness from the basil and other spices, The dough was crunchy and tasty, the cheese and ricotta all blended perfectly they even added pesto to the eggplant and added more basil on the side! We actually met and spoke with the owner who was so sweet, he asked how we liked the pizza and you can tell he’s passionate about the quality of the food. When mom and i said the sauce was very good he said “that’s my grandmas recipe”. I mean, seriously, you know he takes pride in his food when you’re using grandma’s recipe. if you’re in the area you’re lucky because you get to try this pizza. If you live in this area and order regularly then i’m just jealous! Go and get yourself a pie and if you’re a pizza lover snob like me... order enough to have left overs bc you’ll want a slice for lunch the next day, darn now that i wrote this post i really want a slice! Here are some pics, mom and i grabbed the eggplant slice before i could take the pic.

Grumpy’s is hands down the best pizza spot in the area. Everything comes out amazing and the owners are super friendly! This square creamy pesto chicken is my new favorite.

One of the best pies I've had in Jersey. The crust had a crispy exterior but fluffy and chewy inside.